Spread of Zika virus∶The key role of mosquito vector control

Giovanni BenelliInsect Behaviour Group，Department of Agriculture，Food and Environment，University of Pisa，via del Borghetto 80，56124 Pisa，Italy

ABSTRACT

Mosquitoes（Diptera: Culicidae）represent a key threat for millions of humans and animals worldwide，since they act as vectors for important parasites and pathogens，including malaria，filariasis and a wide number of arboviruses. The recent outbreaks of Zika virus infections occurring in South America，Central America，and the Caribbean，represent the most recent four arrivals of important arboviruses in the western hemisphere，over the last 20 years，namely dengue，West Nile virus，and chikungunya. Since there are no specific treatments for Zika virus and the other arboviruses mentioned above，it should be highlighted that the eco-friendly and effective control of mosquito vectors is of pivotal importance. Besides radiation，transgenic and symbiont-based mosquito control approaches，an effective option may be the employ of biological control agents of mosquito young instars，in presence of ultra-low quantities of green-synthesized nanoparticles，which magnify their predation efficiency. Furthermore，behaviour-based control tools relying on the employ of swarming behaviour manipulation（i.e. the“lure and kill”approach），pheromone traps，sound traps need further research attention. In particular，detailed basic information on the physical and chemical cues routing mosquito swarming and mating dynamics is urgently required.



Spread of Zika virus∶The key role of mosquito vector control

Giovanni Benelli*
Insect Behaviour Group，Department of Agriculture，Food and Environment，University of Pisa，via del Borghetto 80，56124 Pisa，Italy

ABSTRACT

Mosquitoes（Diptera: Culicidae）represent a key threat for millions of humans and animals worldwide，since they act as vectors for important parasites and pathogens，including malaria，filariasis and a wide number of arboviruses. The recent outbreaks of Zika virus infections occurring in South America，Central America，and the Caribbean，represent the most recent four arrivals of important arboviruses in the western hemisphere，over the last 20 years，namely dengue，West Nile virus，and chikungunya. Since there are no specific treatments for Zika virus and the other arboviruses mentioned above，it should be highlighted that the eco-friendly and effective control of mosquito vectors is of pivotal importance. Besides radiation，transgenic and symbiont-based mosquito control approaches，an effective option may be the employ of biological control agents of mosquito young instars，in presence of ultra-low quantities of green-synthesized nanoparticles，which magnify their predation efficiency. Furthermore，behaviour-based control tools relying on the employ of swarming behaviour manipulation（i.e. the“lure and kill”approach），pheromone traps，sound traps need further research attention. In particular，detailed basic information on the physical and chemical cues routing mosquito swarming and mating dynamics is urgently required.

Keywords：

Anopheles

Aedes

Culex

Arbovirus

Chikungunya

Dengue

Guillain-Barre syndrome

Microcephaly

Natural product research

Nanoparticles

ARTICLE INFO

Article history：

Received 22 Feb 2016

Received in revised form 2 Mar，2nd revised form 3 Mar 2016

Accepted 27 Mar 2016

Available online 20 Apr 2016

Mini review http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.apjtb.2016.03.012

Tel: +39 0502216141

Fax: +39 0502216087

E-mails: g.benelli@sssup.it，benelli.giovanni@gmail.com

Foundation project: Supported by PROAPI（PRAF 2015）and University of Pisa，Department of Agriculture，Food and Environment（Grant ID. COFIN2015_22）.

Peer review under responsibility of Hainan Medical University. The journal implements double-blind peer review practiced by specially invited international editorial board members.

1. Introduction

Arthropods are dangerous vectors of important pathogens and parasites，which may hit as epidemics or pandemics in the increasing world population of humans and animals［1］. In particular，mosquitoes（Diptera: Culicidae）represent a key threat for millions of humans and animals worldwide，since they act as vectors for important parasites and pathogens，including malaria，filariasis and important arboviruses such as dengue，yellow fever，West Nile，Japanese encephalitis，St. Louis encephalitis viruses（Flaviridae，genus Flavivirus）；chikungunya，Eastern equine encephalitis，Venezuelan equine encephalitis，Western equine encephalitis，Ross River，Sindbis，Mayaro，and Getah viruses（Togaviridae，genus Alphavirus）；Potosi，San Angelo，La Crosse，and Jamestown Canyon viruses（Bunyaviridae，genus Bunyavirus）；Rift Valley fever （Bunyaviridae，genus Phlebovirus）and Orungo viruses （Reoviridae，genus Orbivirus）［2，3］.

Malaria is caused by Plasmodium parasites，mainly Plasmodium falciparum，Plasmodium vivax，Plasmodium ovale and Plasmodium malariae. Notably，periodic reports highlighted the presence of simian malaria parasites found in humans，most of them implicating Plasmodium knowlesi. Plasmodium parasites are vectored to people through the bites of infected Anopheles mosquitoes，which bite mainly between dusk and dawn. There were about 198 million cases of malaria in 2013 and an estimated 584000 deaths. However，malaria mortality rates have fallen by 47%globally since 2000 and by 54%in the African region. Most deaths occur among children living in Africa，where a child dies every minute from malaria. Malaria mortality rates among children in Africa have been reduced by an estimated 58%since 2000［4］. Besides the fall of malaria infectionrates worldwide，with special reference to sub-Saharan Africa，2015 was an annus mirabilis for malaria control，due to the Nobel Prize to the Chinese scientist Youyou Tu for the discovery of artemisinin and the development of the first vaccine against Plasmodium falciparum malaria［i.e. RTS，S/AS01 （RTS，S）］［5］.

2. Zika virus outbreaks

Concerning arboviruses of public health relevance，the occurrence of Zika virus outbreaks have been recently highlighted［5］. Zika virus was first identified in Uganda in 1947 in Rhesus monkeys，within a monitoring network of sylvatic yellow fever. Then，Zika virus has been identified in humans in 1952，in Uganda and the United Republic of Tanzania［6］. In latest years，several important outbreaks of Zika virus have been reported from the Pacific（i.e. Yap Islands，2007；French Polynesia，2013），as well as from the Americas（Brazil and Colombia，2015）and Africa（Cape Verde，2015）. Moreover，thirteen countries more in the Americas have registered sporadic Zika virus infections，highlighting the rapid geographic expansion of this arbovirus［7，8］.

Notably，the recent outbreaks of Zika virus infection occurring in South America，Central America，and the Caribbean，represents the most recent of the four key arrivals of arboviruses in the Western Hemisphere over the last 20 years［9，10］. Indeed，Zika virus follows dengue，West Nile virus，which emerged in 1999，and chikungunya，which emerged in 2013［10，11］. The Zika virus belongs to the genus Flavivirus，and is mainly vectored by Aedes mosquitoes［12］，which are constantly spreading over the continents［5，13，14］.

3. Zika virus symptoms and potential complications

Zika symptoms last from two to seven days，and are comparable to those characterizing other arbovirus infections，with special reference to dengue. Zika virus symptoms include fever，skin rashes，conjunctivitis，muscle and joint pain，malaise，and headache［8］. However，the surveys conducted on the high numbers of cases of Zika virus infections in French Polynesia （2013）and Brazil（2015）highlighted potential neurological and autoimmune complications. During the Zika virus outbreaks in French Polynesia，a concomitant epidemic of 73 cases of Guillain-Barr´e syndrome and other neurologic conditions was observed in a population of about 270000 people［15］. In Northeast Brazil，during 2015，the increase in Zika virus infections has been reported in close concurrence of an increase in babies born with microcephaly［16］. World Health Organization［8］pointed out that further research is urgently needed to shed light on the relationship between these potential complications and Zika virus infections［5］.

4. Zika virus treatment and prevention

Unfortunately，as already known for other arboviruses such as dengue，West Nile and chikungunya，no vaccines or other specific treatments are available，and avoidance of mosquito bites remains the best strategy［2，8］. Current prevention tools are mainly represented by the employ of mosquito repellents［17，18］，light-coloured clothes covering as much of the body as possible，and sleeping under mosquito nets［2］. Concerning chemically derived repellents，the number of these products has been considerably reduced by the European Community. Therefore，there are rather few compounds left，including DEET（N，N-diethyl-m-toluamide），IR3535（3-N-acetyl-N-butylamino-proprionic ethyl ester），icaridin（i.e. Saltidin®，1-piperidine-carboxylic acid 2-2 hydroxyethyl-1-methylester），and also an Eucalyptus citriodora derivative（para-menthane-3，8-diol）［19］.

However，people living in regions with endemic mosquito borne diseases should synergize these strategies with the reduction or removal of Culicidae breeding sites，as well as with mosquitocidal treatments using chemical or microbiological ovicides，larvicides and pupicides［20-26］. Concerning the employ of synthetic pesticides，particular attention should be given to the development of mosquito resistant strains，as well as to concerns for human health and the environment［27，28］.

5. Eco-friendly control of mosquito vectors

Mosquitopopulationcontrolisacrucialtoolinthefightagainst Zika virus infections. Recently，renewed interest has been devoted to the potential of sterile insect technique（SIT）for suppression of mosquito vectors，even if with special reference to the genus Anopheles［29，30］. Notably，SIT has been recently combined with auto-dissemination（i.e. adult females contaminated with dissemination stations of juvenile hormone to treat breeding habitats），a techniquerecentlyprovedefficienttocontrolAedesspeciesbutthat cannot be used at large scales. This has led to formulate a new control concept，named“boosted SIT”that might enable the areawide eradication of mosquitoes and other vectors of medical and veterinaryimportance［31］.Leesetal.［32］alsopointedoutthat，until perfect sexing mechanisms exist，combination of Wolbachiainduced phenotypes，such as cytoplasmic incompatibility and pathogen interference，and irradiation may prove to be the safest solution for population suppression. To enhance the success of these control approaches，detailed basic knowledge about Culicidae mating ecology，with special references of exact behavioural quantification of the events leading to mating success，is urgently needed.

Biological control programs against mosquito young instars are based on the release of predatory aquatic organisms，and this strategy is frequently not suitable in the majority of urban environments exploited by larvae of some Aedes species，therefore further research is required［33］. However，the employ of biological control agents of mosquito young instars in presence of ultra-low quantities of plant-synthesized metal and carbon nanoparticles，may lead to the successful reduction of vector populations，since the sub-lethal doses of these nanoformulations are toxic towards the Culicidae，but not to their natural enemies. Notably，they are also able to boost the biocontrol agent predation rates［34-39］.

6. Conclusions and future challenges

Overall，since there are no specific treatments for Zika virus infection，as well as for other emerging arboviruses of public health relevance，the effective control of mosquito vectors with eco-friendly tools is of crucial importance. Besides the use of synthetic and plant-borne repellents to avoid Culicidae bites，as well as the classic pesticide-based control programs targeting mosquito young instars，further effective options will include radiation，transgenic and symbiont-based control approaches. Inaddition，the employ of biological control agents of mosquito eggs，larvae and pupae，in presence of ultra-low quantities of bioreduced nanoparticles，which boost their predation rates，seems promising.

Lastly，further research on the exact nature of chemical cues routing mate searching and choice dynamics in mosquito vectors is required，as well as behavioural studies dissecting the relative importance of visual（with special reference to swarming landmarks），vibrational，olfactory and tactile cues perceived during swarming and mate recognition. This is of crucial importance to allow the effective applications of swarming manipulation（the “lure and kill”approach），pheromone traps and sound traps［5，40］.

Conflict of interest statement

I declare that I have no conflict of interest.

Acknowledgments

The Author is grateful to H. Mehlhorn and M. Nicoletti for helpful discussion on the topic. G. Benelli is supported by PROAPI（PRAF 2015）and University of Pisa，Department of Agriculture，Food and Environment（Grant ID: COFIN2015_22）. Funders had no role in the study design，data collection and analysis，decision to publish，or preparation of the manuscript.

References

［1］Benelli G，Lo Iacono A，Canale A，Mehlhorn H. Mosquito vectors and the spread of cancer: an overlooked connection？Parasitol Res 2016；http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s00436-016-5037-y.

［2］Benelli G. Research in mosquito control: current challenges for a brighter future. Parasitol Res 2015；114: 2801-5.

［3］Paupy C，Delatte H，Bagny L，Corbel V，Fontenille D. Aedes albopictus，an arbovirus vector: from the darkness to the light. Microb Infect 2009；11: 1177-85.

［4］World Health Organization. Malaria. Geneva: World Health Organization；2014.［Online］Available from: http://www.who.int/ mediacentre/factsheets/fs094/en/［Accessed on 26th February，2016］

［5］Benelli G，Mehlhorn H. Declining malaria，rising dengue and Zika virus: insights for mosquito vector control. Parasitol Res 2016；http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s00436-016-4971-z.

［6］Dick GWA，Kitchen SF，Haddow AJ. Zika virus（I）. Isolations and serological specificity. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg 1952；46: 509-20.

［7］Petersen E，Wilson ME，Touch S，McCloskey B，Mwaba P，Bates M，et al. Rapid spread of Zika virus in the Americas -implications for public health preparedness for mass gatherings at the 2016 Brazil Olympic Games. Int J Infect Dis 2016；44: 11-5.

［8］World Health Organization. Zika virus. Geneva: World Health Organization；2016.［Online］Available from: http://www.who.int/ mediacentre/factsheets/zika/en/［Accessed on 26th February，2016］

［9］Attar N. ZIKA virus circulates in new regions. Nat Rev Microbiol 2016；14: 62.

［10］Fauci AS，Morens DM. Zika virus in the Americas - yet another arbovirus threat. N Engl J Med 2016；374: 601-4.

［11］Morens DM，Fauci AS. Chikungunya at the door-d´ej`a vu all over again？N Engl J Med 2014；371: 885-7.

［12］Marcondes CB，Ximenes MF. Zika virus in Brazil and the danger of infestation by Aedes（Stegomyia）mosquitoes. Rev Soc Bras Med Trop 2016；49: 4-10.

［13］Becker N，Pluskota B，Kaiser A，Schaffner F. Exotic mosquitoes conquer the world. In: Mehlhorn H，editor. Arthropods as vectors of emerging diseases. Berlin: Springer；2012，p. 31-60.

［14］Melaun C，Werblow A，Cunze S，Zotzmann S，Koch LK，Mehlhorn H，et al. Modeling of the putative distribution of the arbovirus vector Ochlerotatus japonicus japonicus（Diptera: Culicidae）in Germany. Parasitol Res 2015；114: 1051-61.

［15］Oehler E，Watrin L，Larre P，Leparc-Goffart I，Last`ere S，Valour F，et al. Zika virus infection complicated by Guillain-Barre syndrome - case report，French Polynesia，December 2013. Euro Surveill 2014；19（9）: 20720.

［16］European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control. Microcephaly in Brazil potentially linked to the Zika virus epidemic，ECDC assesses the risk. Solna: European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control；2015.［Online］Available from: http://ecdc.europa.eu/en/ press/news/_layouts/forms/News_DispForm.aspx？ID=1329&List= 8db7286c-fe2d-476c-9133-18ff4cb1b568&Source=http%3A%2F% 2Fecdc.europa.eu%2Fen%2FPages%2Fhome.aspx［Accessed on 26th February，2016］

［17］Amer A，Mehlhorn H. Repellency effect of forty-one essential oils against Aedes，Anopheles and Culex mosquitoes. Parasitol Res 2006；99: 478-90.

［18］Amer A，Mehlhorn H. The sensilla of Aedes and Anopheles mosquitoes and their importance in repellency. Parasitol Res 2006；99: 491-9.

［19］Abdel-Ghaffar F，Al-Quraishy S，Mehlhorn H. Length of tick repellency depends on formulation of the repellent compound （icaridin = Saltidin®）: tests on Ixodes persulcatus and Ixodes ricinus placed on hands and clothes. Parasitol Res 2015；114: 3041-5.

［20］Amer A，Mehlhorn H. Larvicidal effects of various essential oils against Aedes，Anopheles，and Culex larvae（Diptera，Culicidae）. Parasitol Res 2006；99: 466-72.

［21］Amer A，Mehlhorn H. Persistency of larvicidal effects of plant oil extracts under different storage conditions. Parasitol Res 2006；99: 473-7.

［22］Semmler M，Abdel-Ghaffar F，Al-Rasheid K，Mehlhorn H. Nature helps: from research to products against blood sucking arthropods. Parasitol Res 2009；105: 1483-7.

［23］Pavela R. Essential oils for the development of eco-friendly mosquito larvicides: a review. Ind Crops Prod 2015；76: 174-87.

［24］Benelli G. Plant-borne ovicides in the fight against mosquito vectors of medical and veterinary importance: a systematic review. Parasitol Res 2015；114: 3201-12.

［25］Benelli G. Plant-mediated synthesis of nanoparticles: a newer and safer tool against mosquito-borne diseases？Asian Pac J Trop Biomed 2016；6（4）: 353-4.

［26］Benelli G. Plant-mediated biosynthesis of nanoparticles as an emerging tool against mosquitoes of medical and veterinary importance: a review. Parasitol Res 2016；115: 23-34.

［27］Hemingway J，Ranson H. Insecticide resistance in insect vectors of human disease. Annu Rev Entomol 2000；45: 371-91.

［28］Naqqash MN，G¨okçe A，Bakhsh A，Salim M. Insecticide resistance and its molecular basis in urban insect pests. Parasitol Res 2016；115（4）: 1363-73.

［29］Lees RS，Knols B，Bellini R，Benedict MQ，Bheecarry A，Bossin HC，et al. Review: improving our knowledge of male mosquito biology in relation to genetic control programmes. Acta Trop 2014；132（Suppl）: S2-11.

［30］Bourtzis K，Lees RS，Hendrichs J，Vreysen MJ. More than one rabbit out of the hat: radiation，transgenic and symbiont-based approaches for sustainable management of mosquito and tsetse fly populations. Acta Trop 2016；157: 115-30.

［31］Bouyer J，Lefrançois T. Boosting the sterile insect technique to control mosquitoes. Trends Parasitol 2014；30: 271-3.

［32］Lees RS，Gilles JRL，Hendrichs J，Vreysen MJB，Bourtzis K. Back to the future: the sterile insect technique against mosquito disease vectors. Curr Opin Insect Sci 2015；10: 156-62.

［33］Bowatte G，Perera P，Senevirathne G，Meegaskumbura S，Meegaskumbura M. Tadpoles as dengue mosquito（Aedes aegypti）egg predators. Biol Control 2013；67: 469-74.

［34］Murugan K，Benelli G，Panneerselvam C，Subramaniam J，Jeyalalitha T，Dinesh D，et al. Cymbopogon citratus-synthesized gold nanoparticles boost the predation efficiency of copepodMesocyclops aspericornis against malaria and dengue mosquitoes. Exp Parasitol 2015；153: 129-38.

［35］Murugan K，Priyanka V，Dinesh D，Madhiyazhagan P，Panneerselvam C，Subramaniam J，et al. Predation by Asian bullfrog tadpoles，Hoplobatrachus tigerinus，against the dengue vector，Aedes aegypti，in an aquatic environment treated with mosquitocidal nanoparticles. Parasitol Res 2015；114: 3601-10.

［36］Murugan K，Dinesh D，Jenil Kumar P，Panneerselvam C，Subramaniam J，Madhiyazhagan P，et al. Datura metel-synthesized silver nanoparticles magnify predation of dragonfly nymphs against the malaria vector Anopheles stephensi. Parasitol Res 2015；114: 4645-54.

［37］Murugan K，Nataraj D，Madhiyazhagan P，Sujitha V，Chandramohan B，Panneerselvam C，et al. Carbon and silver nanoparticles in the fight against the filariasis vector Culex quinquefasciatus: genotoxicity and impact on behavioral traits of non-target aquatic organisms. Parasitol Res 2016；115: 1071-83.

［38］ChandramohanB，MuruganK，Panneerselvam C，MadhiyazhaganP，Chandirasekar R，Dinesh D，et al. Characterization and mosquitocidal potential of neem cake-synthesized silver nanoparticles: genotoxicity and impact on predation efficiency of mosquito natural enemies. Parasitol Res 2016；115: 1015-25.

［39］Subramaniam J，Murugan K，Panneerselvam C，Kovendan K，Madhiyazhagan P，Dinesh D，et al. Multipurpose effectiveness of Couroupita guianensis-synthesized gold nanoparticles: high antiplasmodial potential，field efficacy against malaria vectors and synergy with Aplocheilus lineatus predators. Environ Sci Pollut Res Int 2016；23（8）: 7543-58.

［40］Diabate A，Tripet F. Targeting male mosquito mating behaviour for malaria control. Parasit Vectors 2015；8: 347.

*Corresponding author:Giovanni Benelli，Insect Behaviour Group，Department of Agriculture，Food and Environment，University of Pisa，via del Borghetto 80，56124 Pisa，Italy.