最好的老师



最好的老师

责任编辑：李丁文

Mr.Whitson taught sixth-g rade science.On the first day of class,he gave us a lecture about an animal called the Cattywampus,an ill-adapted nocturnal（夜间的）animal that was wiped out during the Ice Age,he passed around a skull（头骨）as he talked.We all took notes and later had a quiz.

When he returned my paper,I was shocked. There was a big red“X”through each of my answ ers.I had failed.There had to be some mistakes!I had written down exactly what Mr. Whitson said.

Then I realized that eve ryone in the class had failed.What had happened?Very simple,Mr. Whitson explained.He had m ade up all that story about the Cattywampus.There had never been any such animal.The information in our notes was,therefore,inco rrect.Did we expect credit for inco rrect answ ers?

Needless to say,we were outraged（激怒）. What kind of text was this?And what kind of teacher is?

We should have figured it out,Mr.Whitson said.After all,at the very moment he was passing around the Cattyw ampus skull(in truth,a cat’s),hadn’t he been telling us that no trace of theanima l remained?He had desc ribed its

惠特森先生教六年级自然科学。第一天上课时，他给我们讲了一种叫卡蒂万波斯的动物，这种动物夜间活动，在冰河时期，因不适应自然环境而灭绝了。他边说边递过一个头颅让我们传看。我们做了笔记，而后进行了测试。

试卷发下来时，我震惊了。每个答案后面都打了一个大大的红“X”，我没及格。一定是弄错了!我写的明明都是惠特森先生讲的。

后来我发现班上同学都没及格。怎么回事?很简单，惠特森先生解释说，所有这些有关卡蒂万波斯的事都是他编造的。这种动物根本就不存在。我们的笔记本上记录的当然是错误的。错误的答案难道还想得分吗？

不必说，我们都很愤怒。这是什么测试?什么老师呀？

我们应该想到这一点，惠特森先生说，毕竟，在他拿出卡蒂万波斯的颅骨 (实际上是猫的颅骨)让我们传看时，不是说这种动物一点儿遗迹都没留下吗？他描绘了它夜间惊人的视觉、皮毛的颜色和他不可能知道的许多情况。他还给这只动物取了个可笑的名字，我们仍未察觉。他说我们测试得零分，会记在记分册上。他真的这样做了。

amazing night vision,the color of its fur and any number of other facts he couldn’t have known, he had given the animal a ridiculous name,and we still hadn’t been suspicious.The zeroes on our papers would be recorded in his grade book, he said.And they were.

Mr.Whitson said he hoped we would learn some thing from this experience.Teachers and textbooks are not always right.In fact,no one is.He told us not to let our minds go to sleep, and to speak up if we ever thought he orthe textbook was wrong.

Every class was anadven ture with Mr. Whitson I can still remember some science periods almost from beginning to end.One day he told us that his Volkswagen（大众汽车，汽车的一种品牌）was a living organism.It took us two full days to put together a refutation he would accept.He didn’t let us off the hook until we had proved not only that we knew what an organism was but a lso that we had the fortitude to stand up for the truth.

G

We carded our brand-new skepticism into all our classes.This caused problems for the other teachers,who weren’t used to being challenged.Our history teacher would be lecturing about some thing,and then there would be clearings of the throat and someone would say “Cattywampus”.

If I’m ever asked to propose a solution to the crisis in our schools,it will be Mr.Whitson. I haven’t made any great scientific discoveries, but Mr.Whitson’s class gave me and my classmates something just as important：the courage to look people in the eye and tell them they are wrong.He also showed us that you can have fun doing it.

惠特森先生说，他希望我们能从这件事中汲取教训：老师和书本并不一定绝对正确。事实上，谁都不可能绝对正确。他让我们开动脑筋，认为他或书本错了，就大胆地说出来。

惠特森先生的每堂课都像是一次历险，他的几堂自然科学课我现在仍记忆犹新。一天，他对我们说，他的大众汽车是一种有生命的生物体。我们花了整整两天的时间，整理他认为可以接受的材料来进行反驳，直到我们证明自己不仅懂得什么是生物体，还能不屈不挠地坚持真理时，他才善罢甘休。

我们持怀疑的态度走入课堂，这给其他老师带来了许多麻烦。他们不习惯受到这样的质疑。历史老师讲课时，下面就会有同学故意咳嗽，然后有人说：“卡蒂万波斯。”

如果有人问我如何解决学校面临的危机时，那就是惠特森先生的教学方法。我没有任何伟大的科学发现，但是惠特森先生的课给我和同学们一个重要的启示：我们要正视别人的眼睛，勇敢地告诉他们，他们错了。他也同样指出我们的不足，这会获得无穷的乐趣。

（Wendy编译）

The Best Teacher I Ever Had