Efficient Electromagnetic Wave Absorption and Thermal Infrared Stealth in PVTMS@MWCNT Nano-Aerogel via Abundant Nano-Sized Cavities and Attenuation Interfaces

Haoyu Ma, Maryam Fashandi, Zeineb Ben Rejeb, Xin Ming, Yingjun Liu,Pengjian Gong, Guangxian Li, Chul B.Park,✉

ABSTRACT Pre-polymerized vinyl trimethoxy silane (PVTMS)@MWCNT nano-aerogel system was constructed via radical polymerization, sol-gel transition and supercritical CO2 drying.The fabricated organic-inorganic hybrid PVTMS@MWCNT aerogel structure shows nano-pore size (30-40 nm), high specific surface area (559 m2 g-1),high void fraction (91.7%) and enhanced mechanical property: (1) the nano-pore size is beneficial for efficiently blocking thermal conduction and thermal convection via Knudsen effect (beneficial for infrared (IR)stealth); (2) the heterogeneous interface was beneficial for IR reflection(beneficial for IR stealth) and MWCNT polarization loss (beneficial for electromagnetic wave (EMW) attenuation); (3) the high void fraction was beneficial for enhancing thermal insulation (beneficial for IR stealth) and EMW impedance match (beneficial for EMW attenuation).Guided by the above theoretical design strategy, PVTMS@MWCNT nano-aerogel shows superior EMW absorption property (cover all Ku-band) and thermal IR stealth property (ΔT reached 60.7 °C).Followed by a facial combination of the above nano-aerogel with graphene film of high electrical conductivity, an extremely high electromagnetic interference shielding material (66.5 dB, 2.06 mm thickness) with superior absorption performance of an average absorption-to-reflection(A/R) coefficient ratio of 25.4 and a low reflection bandwidth of 4.1 GHz (A/R ratio more than 10) was experimentally obtained in this work.

KEYWORDS Nano-pore size; Heterogeneous interface; Electromagnetic wave absorption; Thermal infrared stealth; Nano-aerogel

1 Introduction

New generation materials with both superior electromagnetic wave (EMW) absorption property and infrared (IR)stealth property have received widespread attention due to their important application potentials, especially in the field of human health protection, precision instrument protection and modern military [1-3].For example, in modern military area, materials with both IR stealth and EMW absorption property were beneficial for developing IR and EMW double stealth device.However, microwave absorbers need low reflectivity and high absorptivity, while IR stealth materials require high reflectivity and low IR absorptivity [3].Thus,it seems to be challenging to integrate IR and EMW stealth in one material owing to the thoroughly opposite principles.Therefore, lots of effort have been made to prepare materials with both EMW absorption and IR stealth properties.

For EMW absorption materials, interfacial polarization loss [4, 5], conduction loss [6, 7] and multi-reflection loss[8] have been proven to be efficient methods to absorb the incident EMW.For example, Zhou et al.[9] fabricated multiheterogeneous interface structure in CoNi/C aerogel, due to the enhanced interfacial polarization loss and the impedance match, hence achieved a minimum reflection loss value of -60.7 dB.Ma et al.[6] utilized conduction loss and polarization loss of graphene nanoribbon (GNR) structure in the cell wall of GNR/poly(vinylidene fluoride) nanocomposites foam, hence achieved high EMW absorption property (-54.1 dB).Xu et al.[8] fabricated reduced graphene oxide@ferroferric oxide (Fe3O4)/carbon nanotube/tetraneedle-like ZnO whisker@silver/waterborne polyurethane composite foams with aligned porous structures, hence achieved broadband microwave absorption performance (in the frequency range of 8.2-18.0 GHz) due to the multi-reflection of EMW and the progressive conductive structure design.However, it should be noted that the absorbed EMW energy via polarization loss, conduction loss and multi-reflection loss will be transformed into joule heat [10].And if EMW energies are transformed into heat, the target surface temperature will increase and can be easily detected by IR detectors, hence deteriorating the IR stealth property [11].

Porous structure is beneficial for preparing superior IR stealth materials; because the high void fraction leads to decreased thermal conductivity and air/solid interface structure enhances IR reflection.Gu et al.[3] coated poly(3, 4-ethy lenedioxythiophene):polystyrene sulfonate on melamine foam surface (with micrometer pore size) to create heterogeneous interface in porous structure, hence prepared materials with desired IR stealth property (ΔTreached to 35.9 °C).Wu et al.[12] used freeze-drying method to prepare porous reduced graphene oxide/Fe3O4materials (with micrometer pore size)and the IR stealth property (ΔT) reached 34.8 °C.Therefore,porous materials (containing air phase) show great potential for preparing high-performance IR stealth materials.However, it should be also noted that solid skeleton in micrometer porous materials could be an idealized thermal conduction pathway,which will deteriorate the IR stealth property of materials [13].

Nano-aerogel materials (with nano-sized air distribution)could be used for more effectively blocking thermal conduction and IR signal due to the unique structure including nano-pore size, high specific surface area and high void fraction [14, 15].For IR stealth materials, nano-pore size of aerogel materials will induce Knudsen effect and greatly restrict the free movement of air molecules, hence greatly decreasing the thermal conduction (even lower than air) and thermal convection of nano-aerogel materials [16, 17]; high specific interface area will be beneficial for enhancing the IR wave reflection and improving IR stealth property of materials according to the Stefan-Boltzmann theory [18]; High void fraction will be beneficial for decreasing the thermal conduction of materials and improving the EMW impedance match, hence beneficial for enhancing the IR stealth property and EMW absorption property, simultaneously.

In this work, pre-polymerized vinyl trimethoxy silane(PVTMS) with high cross-linking density was synthesized using the radical polymerization method, and then the spinodal decomposition method was used to prepare PVTMS@MWCNT/ethanol wet-gel.Then, supercritical CO2(scCO2) drying method was used to prepare PVTMS@MWCNT nano-aerogel with high void fraction,high specific surface area and nano-pore size.It is found that the high void fraction was beneficial to enhance the EMW impedance match and the tailored MWCNT heterogeneous interface was beneficial to enhance EMW polarization loss (electron transporting) and electron tunneling loss of PVTMS@MWCNT nano-aerogel.Therefore, allfrequency absorption inKu-band (12.4-18 GHz) could be achieved with an optimized MWCNT nanofiller structure.The EMW absorption property of obtained PVTMS@MWCNT nano-aerogel even reached -36.1 dB.Meanwhile, the high specific surface area was beneficial for enhancing the IR reflection and nano-pore size was beneficial for decreasing the thermal conductivity of PVTMS@MWCNT nano-aerogel, hence greatly enhancing the IR stealth property (ΔTreached 60.7 °C).Then, by simply combining this EMW absorption aerogel layer (PVTMS@MWCNT nano-aerogel) with an ultra-thin graphene film layer, a high EMI shielding material with excellent EMW absorption property (an averageA/Rratio of 25.4 and EMW absorption bandwidth (EBW) of 4.1 GHz) was successfully fabricated in this work.Therefore, from both experimental and theoretical viewpoints, this work provides a guideline for nano-scale structural designation of porous materials in the application of EMW absorbing,EMI shielding and IR stealth.

2 Experimental

2.1 Materials

Di-tert-butyl peroxide (DTBP, 98%, thermal initiator) and vinyl trimethoxy silane (VTMS, 98%, silica precursor) were purchased from Sigma-Aldrich.Anhydrous ethanol (100%,solvent) and ammonium hydroxide solution (28-30%, ACS Grade, base catalyst) were purchased from GreenField Global and VWR, respectively.All the chemicals were used as received.Multi-walled carbon nanotubes (MWCNTs, diameter: 9.5 nm; length: 1.5 μm) were purchased from Nanocyl SA, Belgium (NC7000™).Carbon dioxide(purity ≥ 99%, Linde Gas) was used for scCO2drying.

2.2 Sample Preparation

2.2.1 Polymeric Precursor Synthesis

PVTMS was prepared by the method discussed in our previous studies [19, 20].First, 6 g of DTBP was dissolved in 60 g of VTMS and poured into a three-neck flask equipped with a condenser and stirrer.The reaction was initiated under a nitrogen atmosphere at 150 °C with a stirring speed of 200 rpm.After 3 h, the flask was placed in a vacuum oven at a temperature of 150 °C to remove the unreacted monomer and initiator.

2.2.2 Sol-Gel Synthesis of Hybrid Aerogels

As shown in Fig.1a, 4 g PVTMS was dissolved in 20 mL ethanol and the solution was then stirred at 40 °C for 0.5 h.A certain amount of nanofiller was added to 20 mL ethanol solution followed by sonication for 0.5 h in a bath sonicator.The above two batches of ethanol solutions were then mixed and followed by a continuous stirring for another 0.5 h.After mixing, the base catalyst with water/Si molar ratio of 8 was added to the mixture for inducing spinodal decomposition.The mixture was further stirred for 1 more minute followed by transferring to the molds.The molds were kept in an oven at 40 °C for up to 12 h until gelation was completed.The wet gels were aged in ethanol for 24 h and,finally, went through solvent exchange with liquid CO2at a pressure of 10.34 MPa (1500 psi), and dried with scCO2at 45 °C.

2.2.3 Double-Layered PVTMS@MWCNT/Graphene Samples

Graphene films with superior electrical conductivity and EMW reflection property was prepared via solvent casting and thermal reduction [21-23], and the total thickness is around 0.03 mm.Then, PVTMS@MWCNT nanocomposite aerogel was combined with reflection layer (graphene film) using glue to prepare double layer aerogel/graphene EMI shielding materials.

2.3 Characterization

Transmission electron microscope (TEM, Talos F200i)was used to study the microstructure of the aerogels.X-ray photoelectron spectroscope (XPS, Thermo Scientific K-Alpha) was used to study the element content of pristine PVTMS, PVTMS@MWCNT aerogel.The total thermal conductivity of the aerogel samples was measured using a Hot Disk TPS2500S thermal constants analyzer.Pore size distribution and the surface area of PVTMS@MWCNT aerogel were also measured by the Brunauer-Emmett-Teller (BET) test using an Autosorb IQ (Quantachrome Instruments).Infrared thermal imaging photos with the information of different sample’(thickness: 5.6 mm) surface temperature and infrared stealth property were taken by an infrared imaging device(Fluke-Ti32S).

PNA-X network analyzer (Keysight N5232B) was used to evaluate EMW absorption property (single layer) and EMI shielding property of samples [24, 25].According to waveguide method, real and imaginary parts of permittivity (ε′ andε″) and permeability (μ′ andμ″) of PVTMS@MWCNT aerogel inKu-band frequency range(12.4-18 GHz) were tested.EMW absorption performance(Reflection Loss, RL) and impedance match (Zin/Z0) can be calculated by the measured complex permittivity and permeability using the following equations [26, 27]:

whereZinis the input impedance of the material (Ω) andZ0refers to the impedance of free space (normally 377 Ω).μrandεrrefer to the complex permeability and permittivity of the material, respectively.fanddrepresent the applied EMW frequency (Hz) and the thickness (m) of the material.cis the speed of light (m/s).

To determine the EMW attenuation capability of the material, the attenuation constantαcan be evaluated by the equation:

The scattering parameters, S11and S21, were used to calculate the total SE (SET), reflection SE (SER), and absorption SE (SEA).R,TandAcoefficients were also calculated from the scattering parameters,S11andS21[28, 29].

3 Results and Discussion

3.1 PVTMS@MWCNT Aerogel Preparation and the Corresponding Structure Characterization

As Fig.1a shown, PVTMS polymer chain with high inorganic cross-linking density was prepared using radical polymerization method.The high cross-linking density was beneficial for fabricating aerogel with nano-pore size and high surface area, and the hybrid organic-inorganic molecular structure was beneficial for enhancing mechanical property of nano-aerogel materials [30, 31].Then, spinodal decomposition method was used to prepare PVTMS@MWCNT wet gel (Fig.1a), through this method, sol-gel transition speed could be greatly enhanced [32, 33].Finally,in order to achieve nano-pore structure and high specific surface area, scCO2drying method was used to prepare PVTMS@MWCNT nano-aerogel (Fig.1b) [19].The fabricated PVTMS@MWCNT nano-aerogel with abundant heterogeneous interface (Part 1), multilayer of PVTMS molecular structure (Part 2) and nano-pore size structure (Part 3)was beneficial for enhancing EMW absorption property,mechanical property and IR stealth property.

Figure 2a, b shows TEM micrographs of pristine PVTMS nano-aerogel and PVTMS@MWCNT nano-aerogel, and they all show nano-pore size structure.Figure 2c shows digital micrograph of PVTMS@MWCNT aerogel with various nanofiller content, it is noted that the degree of aerogel shrinkage decreased with increasing MWCNT content after scCO2drying (Fig.S3).For aerogel with nano-pore size,the capillary force in solvent exchange process is the main reason for aerogel shrinkage.As Fig.1 (Part 2) and Fig.S2 show, PVTMS molecular chains could be absorbed on MWCNTs’ surface due to hydrogen bonding effect and Van der Waals forces adsorption effect [34-36].Then, the highdensity PVTMS aerogel layer could be generated around MWCNT during sol-gel transition process, and the highdensity layer around MWCNT network will be beneficial for enhancing the solid skeleton strength and decreasing the shrinkage ratio during scCO2drying process.

Figure 2d shows thermal conductivity and void fraction of PVTMS@MWCNT nano-aerogel with various MWCNT contents.The void fraction slightly increased from 90.9 to 92% with increasing MWCNT content, and the thermal conductivity also increased from 25.3 to 42.4 mW m-1K-1with increasing MWCNT content.The increased void fraction could be ascribed to the decreased shrinkage ratio due to the enhanced solid skeleton strength around MWCNTs;the increased thermal conductivity could be ascribed to the high thermal conductivity of MWCNTs.However, due to the high void fraction (large amount of air) and nano-pore size (Knudsen effect), PVTMS@MWCNT nano-aerogel still shows low thermal conductivity.Figure 2e presents that the low thermal conductivity PVTMS@MWCNT nano-aerogel could be used to effectively block the heat transfer and hence suppress the water evaporation process of the flower on the nano-aerogel upper surface.Figure 2f shows the compressive mechanical property of PVTMS@MWCNT nanoaerogel with various MWCNT content, and the mechanical property increased by adding MWCNTs to form solid absorption layer (Fig.1(Part 2)).Figure 2g, h shows overall XPS spectral and C 1sXPS spectral of pristine PVTMS aerogel and PVTMS@MWCNT aerogel.It is noted that the C 1scharacteristic peak at 284.8 eV greatly increased, which can be ascribed to the added MWCNTs (C=C or C-C).The increased carbon nanofiller is then beneficial for the construction of EMW absorption structure to effectively absorb the incident EMW.

3.2 EMW Absorption Property of PVTMS@MWCNT Aerogel

Figure 3a, b shows electromagnetic parameters (permittivity) of PVTMS@MWCNT nano-aerogel with various nanofiller content.The average electromagnetic parameters are presented in Fig.3c, it is noted that the real part(ε′) and imaginary part (ε″) of dielectric permittivity all increased with increasing nanofiller content.The increased dielectric permittivity could be ascribed to the increased MWCNT content, and the increased dielectric loss could be ascribed to the increased conduction loss in nanocomposites with increasing MWCNT content [37, 38].Figure 3d shows the attenuation constant (α) of PVTMS@MWCNT nano-aerogel with various nanofiller contents.The attenuation constant increases with increasing nanofiller content, which is ascribed to the conduction loss of MWCNTs.

Figure 3e-h and e’-h’ shows the EMW absorption property of PVTMS@MWCNT nano-aerogel with various MWCNT contents in both 3D and 2D.It is noted that the EMW absorption property of PVTMS@MWCNT nanoaerogel increased first and then decreased with increasing nanofiller content.Figure 3e”-h” shows the impedance match of PVTMS@MWCNT nano-aerogel at various thickness.It is noted that impedance match (Zin/Z0) of aerogel material gradually decreases with increasing MWCNT content.As Fig.3f’’ shows, the impedance match of PVTMS@MWCNT nano-aerogel reached to 1, which means the lower reflection ratio of EMW at air/material interface.And the decreased reflection ratio will be beneficial for EMW absorption [39].Hence, as Fig.3f, f’ shown, the best EMW absorption property (all-Kuband, RLmin= -36.1 dB,2 mm in thickness) was achieved by tailoring the MWCNT structure in PVTMS nano-aerogel system.As Figs.S7 and S8 show, the superior EMW absorption property could be ascribed to heterogeneous interface polarization loss and tunnelling loss.

Meanwhile, it is also noted that optimal EMW absorption thickness gradually decreases with increasing MWCNT content, this could be ascribed to the following two reasons: (1) the optimal impedance thickness gradually decreases with increasing MWCNT content; (2) The optimal EMW absorption thickness (T) could be expressed as follows [40]:

wherecis the speed of light,μrandεrrefer to the complex permeability and permittivity of the material, respectively.frepresents the applied EMW frequency.Therefore, the optimal EMW absorption thickness gradually decreases with increasing dielectric property (Fig.3a).

3.3 IR Stealth Property of PVTMS@MWCNT Aerogel

Figure 4 shows nitrogen adsorption-desorption isotherms of pristine PVTMS aerogel and PVTMS@MWCNT aerogel.The pore shapes and types were investigated based on IUPAC’s technical report on the physisorption of gases [41].It can be observed that all samples exhibit type IV isotherm,which is a characteristic of mesoporous materials [41].The hysteresis loop is generated due to the capillary condensation in mesopores with a diameter over 4 nm.Nitrogen adsorption-desorption analysis was also used to measure the specific surface area and pore size of the samples [20].As Fig.4a, b shows, PVTMS@MWCNT aerogel shows high specific surface area (559 m2g-1) and nano pore size(30-40 nm).

Fig.5 a-d Schematic illustration of double-layered EMI shielding materials combining PVTMS@MWCNT nano-aerogel (top layer) and graphene film layer (bottom layer); a’-d’ EMI shielding effectiveness (SE) of double-layered samples with various nano-aerogel layer thickness,and a’’-d’’ the corresponding reflection (R), transmission (T) and absorption values together a’’’-d’’’ with A/R ratio

In order to characterize the infrared stealth property of our PVTMS@MWCNT nano-aerogel, samples were placed on a heating platform at various temperatures (67.1, 82.4 and 100.1 °C) and thermal infrared images were captured.Figure 4f-i” shows thermal infrared images of PVTMS@MWCNT nano-aerogel captured at intervals of 8 min from 0 to 16 min at various heat source temperature including 67.1,82.4 and 100.1 °C.The detailed upper surface temperature is presented in Fig.4c, it is noted that the target signal was greatly decreased by covering PVTMS@MWCNT nanoaerogel on the hot plate, and the ΔTreached to 60.7 °C.

For thermal IR steal materials, low IR emissivity and low thermal conductivity are key factors for enhancing IR stealth property.As Fig.S11 shows, it is noted that PVTMS@MWCNT samples shows high infrared emissivity (0.95 at 3-5 μm and 0.94 at 8-14 μm).The proposed reason for the high infrared emissivity could be ascribed to the added MWCNT, which could act as black body, hence, to absorb and emit IR signal [16].Figures 4e and S12 shows the IR stealth mechanism of PVTMS@MWCNT nano-aerogel.Generally, heat transfer mechanism including thermal radiation, thermal conduction and thermal convection.For PVTMS@MWCNT nano-aerogel, the high specific surface area and high void fraction were beneficial for blocking thermal radiation by reflectance and decreasing solid-phase thermal conduction, respectively; the nano-pore size was beneficial for blocking gas-phase thermal conduction and thermal convection via Knudsen effect.Hence, PVTMS@MWCNT nano-aerogel shows superior IR stealth property.

Fig.6 a Infrared stealth property [2, 3, 42-45] and b EMW absorption property [6, 7, 46-54] of PVTMS@MWCNT aerogel compared with references; c EMI shielding property of double-layered PVTMS@MWCNT aerogel/graphene film compared with references [8, 55-63]

3.4 Double-Layered PVTMS@MWCNT/Graphene Film for EMI Shielding

PVTMS@MWCNT aerogel also shows great potential for preparing double-layered material with superior EMI shielding property (absorption dominant).Hence, in this work,graphene film with high electrical conductivity and high EMW reflection property was used as the EMW reflection layer (bottom film layer) to construct a double-layered EMI shielding material with EMW absorption aerogel layer on top, as shown in Fig.5.For pristine graphene film layer shown in Fig.5d, d’, d’’ and d’’’, most incident EMW was reflected at the interface between air/graphene film (averageR= 0.98) due to the film’s very high electrical conductivity.However, for those double-layered EMI shielding material,the reflection (SER) greatly decreased and almost all of total EMI shielding (SET) were from absorption (SEA).As shown in Fig.5b’’, b’’’, the double-layered absorption material of ～ 2 mm in thickness with a reflection film shows the best EMW absorption property for EMI shielding application.The maximumA/Rratio reached to 72.3 and the averageA/Rratio inKuband was 25.4.The efficient EMW absorption bandwidth (EBW,A/R> 10) was 4.1 GHz.

Figure 6 summaries a series of studies on IR stealth (a),EMW absorption (b) and EMI shielding (c), it is noted that the fabricated PVTMS@MWCNT nano-aerogel shows superior IR stealth property, EMW absorption property and EMI shielding property, simultaneously.The main reason for this superior property could be ascribed to the tailored nano-sized cavities and abundant heterogeneous interface fabricated in PVTMS@MWCNT nano-aerogel system.

4 Conclusion

In this work, MWCNT network structure with superior EMW absorption property was constructed in prepolymerized vinyl trimethoxy silane (PVTMS) nanoaerogel system.Supercritical CO2drying technology and spinodal decomposition method were used to prepare

organic-inorganic hybrid PVTMS aerogel structure with nano-pore size, high specific surface area, high void fraction and enhanced mechanical property: (1) the nano pore size is beneficial for efficiently blocking thermal conduction and thermal convection; (2) the abundant heterogeneous interface was beneficial for IR refection and EMW absorption; (3) the high void fraction was beneficial for enhancing EMW impedance match of samples; Guided by the above theoretical design strategy, EMW absorbing PVTMS@MWCNT nano-aerogel with a -36.1 dB absorption performance cover allKu-band (12.4-18 GHz) was successfully fabricated using the tailored structure design;and the PVTMS@MWCNT nano-aerogel shows superior IR stealth property (ΔTreached to 60.7 °C).Followed by a facial combination of the above nano-aerogel with graphene film of high electrical conductivity, an extremely high EMI shielding material (66.5 dB, 2.06 mm thickness) with superior absorption performance of an average absorption-to-reflection (A/R) ratio of 25.4 and a low refection bandwidth of 4.1 GHz (A/Rratio more than 10)was experimentally obtained in this work.

AcknowledgementsThe authors are grateful to the National Natural Science Foundation (No.52073187) and NSAF Foundation (No.U2230202) for their financial support of this project.We are also thankful to the support from National Natural Science Foundation(No.51721091), Programme of Introducing Talents of Discipline to Universities (No.B13040), State Key Laboratory of Polymer Materials Engineering (No.sklpme2022-2-03).The first author is grateful for the support of China Scholarship Council.

Declarations

Conflict of interestThe authors declare no interest conflict.They have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.

Open AccessThis article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use,sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made.The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material.If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use,you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder.To view a copy of this licence, visit http:// creat iveco mmons.org/ licen ses/ by/4.0/.

Supplementary InformationThe online version contains supplementary material available at https:// doi.org/ 10.1007/s40820- 023- 01218-y.